Skip to content

Andres Torres Out; Some Thoughts on What to Do

September 13, 2010

According to Andrew Baggarly (and other various reporters), Giants center fielder/leadoff man/offensive stalwart Andres Torres is out for at least ten days after having an appendectomy.  Considering that the Giants are currently tied with the San Diego Padres for first place in the National League West with only eighteen games remaining, this is what I’d call a devastating blow.

Torres has been an asset both offensively and defensively.  Offensively, he’s provided the Giants with about +11 runs above the average hitter and an additional +7 runs on the basepaths, whilst saving the pitching staff approximately 17 runs with the glove.  That’s an invaluable player, especially one on a team that is very much a station-to-station ball club that is below average with Torres (-4) and is infinitely worse without (around -11).  Dude hits a lot of doubles, legs out a number of triples, and has hit a surprising amount of home runs.  Defensively, he’s a necessity to a pitching staff that is forced to pitch with a water buffalo in Pat Burrell over in left and a human snail in Jose Guillen over in right.  With Torres gone, the outfield defense isn’t exactly what I’d call compromised- Rowand is adequate- but we need something better than that to account for the lack of range in the corners.

The question is, what do we do now to help offset the loss?  Bruce Bochy appears to think playing Aaron Rowand in center field will work, and I’m okay with that.  The other would be to play Rowand and Cody Ross, and to sit Guillen.  Guillen’s hit better than both Ross and Rowand this year, but his defense is substantially weaker than those two.  Personally, I’d feel more comfortable with Ross in right- or at least taking the majority of the at-bats- than Guillen.  I’m of the state of mind that with a relatively weak offense- that’s being carried by Posey, Burrell and Huff- having a plus defender in right with the loss of Torres would be ideal.  But I can understand choosing Guillen over Ross, to a certain extent.  The one thing that I cannot ever agree with, however, is having Rowand hit leadoff.  The guy’s a black hole in the lineup, and the last place you want to put him is in a position that gets a lot of plate appearances.  I’d much prefer to have Sanchez hitting leadoff.  Or anyone else, for that matter.

3 Comments leave one →
  1. sk8888 permalink
    September 13, 2010 9:36 PM

    I wonder what Nate Schierholtz needs to do to get his name in the conversation? Be a better fielder than Guillen? Have more knowledge about our yard’s RF? As recently as this past road trip, gotten some timely, and/or game winning hits? Hit homeruns against the Dodgers?

    If there is one “experiment” that makes the most sense right now, it’s starting Nate Schierholtz. He doesn’t have to bat lead-off, but with Torres out, we need someone who isn’t still learning our yard. We need someone who can help our pitchers stay in the game by tracking down line drives with their speed. His bat couldn’t be much worse than Rowand or Ross and he’s got far more upside for the reasons listed above than Guillen, Rowand or Ross.

    • triplesalley permalink*
      September 14, 2010 1:40 AM

      Wow, I completely forgot about Schierholtz. It’s so rare to see him make an appearance that I didn’t even think of him as a starter! Absolutely, Nate should be another option.

      What does Nate have to do? He has to be in his mid-30’s if he wants to get a chance, basically.

      • Kool permalink
        September 14, 2010 5:37 PM

        LOL But can Bochy keep it in his pants till then?

        I would be most happy with Ross in CF and Nate in RF. Ross really hasn’t played much since we got him, but, I think that given the chance he would hit at least as much as Rowand has hit (plus with some VROOM! and a better glove).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: